Located at the Morgan County Historical Society, McConnelsville, Ohio. This organ was purchased from a McConnelsville, Ohio, merchant, H.B. Vincent, on 17 July 1896. It was the first organ in the First Presbyterian Church, McConnelsville, Ohio. It was later replaced by a pipe organ. It was donated to the museum by James Galen Finley, a member of the church.

Although not mentioned, Estey advertised the Cottage Organs from the late 1860s to the early 1870s. The church must have picked this one up secound hand in 1896.